Supporting copy for the Request Service call out button.
Hilltop Bagel Café - logo
"Simple & Fresh"
BAGELS
Serving Farmingville and the Surrounding Areas | Located in Farmingville, NY
631-846-1828
Serving Farmingville and the Surrounding Areas | Located in Farmingville, NY
Call Us Today

Old-Fashioned Kettle Baked Bagels

Hilltop Bagel Café old-fashioned kettle baked bagels, made fresh every morning. Choose from our variety of bagels such as French Toast, Sesame, Blueberry, Plain and etc. You'll also be pleased to know that we have sports and school themed bagels of various colors. We serve bagel thins in assorted colors and themes. 
Bagels

Cream Cheese Flavors

  • Birthday cake
  • Oreo Cookies & Cream
  • S'mores
  • Honey maple walnut raisin
  • Rocky Road
  • Bacon and cheddar
  • Rainbow cookie
  • Fruity pebbles
  • Cotton candy
  • Lucky charms
  • Nut N Honey
  • Black cherry overload
  • Apple pie
  • Jelly Ring
  • Pistachio Nut
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Strawberry Shortcake
  • And much more

Seasonal flavors

  • Pumpkin
  • Holy Cannoli
  • Orange
  • Green
  • Red
  • Jalapeño Salsa

Our Menu

Cream Cheese (Price per Pound)

Plain
$9.99 +TAX
Specialty Cream Cheese
$10.99 +TAX
Lox Cream Cheese
$11.99 +TAX
Sliced Nova
$36.99 +TAX
We also offer catering, call us today for more details.

Our Menu

Bagels

Bagel
$1.50
W/ Butter
$3.00 +TAX
W/ Cream Cheese

$4.00 +TAX
W/ Flavored Cream Cheese
$5.00+TAX
W/ Cream Cheese + Bacon
$6.00 +TAX
1/2 Dozen
$9.00
1 Dozen
$18.00

Plates


Pancakes

W/ Ham or Bacon Add $1.99 +TAX W/ Sausage or Turkey Add $1.99 +TAX

$8.00+TAX
French Toast

W/ Ham or Bacon Add $1.99 +TAX W/ Sausage or Turkey Add $1.99 +TAX

$8.00 +TAX
Side of Home fries
$4.99 +TAX

Egg Sandwiches

Includes a 6 oz juice before 11 am

2 Eggs* on a Bagel
$6.25 +TAX
W/ Cheese
$7.25 +TAX
W/ Bacon or Ham
$8.25 +TAX
W/ Sausage or Turkey
$8.50 +TAX
W/ Bacon or Ham + Cheese
$8.50 +TAX
W/ Sausage or Turkey + Cheese
$8.75 +TAX
Breakfast Wrap

3 eggs* on a wrap with meat + cheese

$9.75 +TAX
Hungryman

3 eggs* on a hero with ham, sausage, bacon + cheese

$10.99 +TAX
Sandwich Extras

Egg* $1 +TX

Bacon or Ham $2.99 +TX

Cheese $1 +TX

Sausage or Turkey $2.99+TX

$2.99 +TAX

Add home fries to any sandwich for $4.99




$4.99 +TAX
Buy a dozen bagels for $18.00!
Visit us today!

"French toast bagels are the best!!!"

-Mary McGowan Feiler
Click Here for Closed Captioning
Bagel
Bagel

*All Prices Are Subject To Change

Share by: